recipes
Our Make Mock Turtle Soup Recipe: A Delicious and Easy Treat

Our Make Mock Turtle Soup Recipe: A Delicious and Easy Treat

I may have been compensated for this post. Please keep in mind that it affects you in no way financially. If an item is being reviewed, I am not obligated to give a positive review and always use my own words. This disclosure is in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising. If you would like a review done contact Dannelle at op40k@aol.com

Looking for an easy and delicious recipe? Look no further than our mock turtle soup recipe! This dish is perfect for a winter meal, and it’s sure to please your guests. Plus, it’s easy to make – you just need a few simple ingredients. We’ll show you how to prepare this soup step-by-step, so you can make it at home with ease.

how to make the best mock turtle soup recipe

History of Turtle Soup

Turtle soup has been around for centuries, and it was once a very popular dish. In fact, turtle soup was so popular that it was often served at British royal banquets. The soup was also considered to be a luxurious dish, and it was often served to wealthy guests.

Real turtle soup was even served in the White House by Eisenhower. You can see his green turtle soup recipe here. It had been savored by presidents like John Adams and William Howard Taft and even served at Roosevelt’s 42nd birthday dinner.

However, turtle soup fell out of favor in the mid-20th century. This is because turtles became increasingly rare, and they were also more difficult to prepare. As a result, mock turtle soup became popular. Mock turtle soup is made with beef or veal, and it resembles turtle soup in flavor and texture.

Turtle Soup and the Cayman Islands

Turtle soup is still popular in some parts of the world, including the Cayman Islands. In fact, the Cayman Turtle Farm is one of the largest turtle farms in the world. The farm raises over 200,000 turtles each year, and it produces about 40% of the turkeys consumed in the Cayman Islands.

The Cayman Turtle Farm is also a major tourist attraction, and it’s one of the most popular places to visit on the island. Visitors can tour the farm, see the turtles, and even eat turtle soup. I am not really sure how I feel about that…

What Kinds of Turtles Were Used in a Turtle Soup Recipe?

There are many different kinds of turtles, and they can be found all over the world. However, the most common type of turtle that was used in turtle soup is the green sea turtle. Green sea turtles are found in tropical and subtropical waters, and they’re a popular choice for soup because of their large size. Today? We are too busy saving these gentle giants to want to eat them.

How to Make Mock Turtle Soup: A Delicious and Easy Recipe

Original Mock Turtle Soups

These tended to use calf’s brains and calf’s head as a substitution for turtle meat when they became endangered which does not sound all that appetizing to me. It would take a lot of time to prepare, usually about 24 hours. I also would have a hard time using veal…but calf brain soup recipes have been popular in Europe for centuries.

No Turtles Are Harmed in this Recipe

Mock Turtle Soup is, as the name suggests, a copycat of traditional Green Turtle Soup but instead of using the turtle as your protein source, you will substitute that for beef in place of turtle meat. 

Link to purchase 100 Things WI book

Mock Turtle Soup

Soup lovers from around the world can enjoy Mock Turtle soup! Its simple ingredients are easy to find and the results are a flavorful bowl of comforting soup.  This soup can be used for several occasions and celebrations, from a family evening dinner to a birthday bash. Children are bound to love this ‘cookie’ soup and parents will love that it is packed with protein. A wonderful spin on a classic turtle soup, leaving you wanting more.

Why You Are Going To Love This: 

Although the ingredients may sound strange you will have to trust the process in the recipe because this flavorful and full-bodied soup is sure to be a hit in your house! It’s a great source of protein and will leave you and your family feeling satisfied. The ginger snaps will give the dish a kick of flavor and the ketchup will offer a sweetness. 

What Do I Need To Make Mock Turtle Soup?

mock turtle soup recipe ingredients

These ingredients are easy to find in any market or grocery store and some of them you may already have in your cabinet or fridge. This home recipe doesn’t use beef broth, sherry, or bay leaves. Start by gathering the following:

  • Ground lean Beef – or any ground meat of choice: pork, ground turkey, etc. instead of turtle meat would do
  • Ginger snap cookies – I tend to get these at the local dollar store
  • Yellow large onion – these are the most inexpensive and offer the best flavor
  • Ketchup – I stick with Heinze but that is my personal preference
  • Worcestershire sauce – this will give the soup a bit of depth
  • Lemon slices – for garnish and the fresh lemon juice that we associate with fresh seafood
  • Hard-boiled eggs – this really adds a layer of texture to your soup
  • Salt & ground black pepper – to taste
  • Water – to thin out the soup as it cooks
  • Fresh Parsley for garnish

How to Make Our Mock Turtle Soup Recipe

mock turtle soup recipe cooking beef

In a large pot brown ground beef and yellow onion over medium heat. Drain the grease if it is needed.

mock turtle soup recipe soaking gingersnaps

Place the ginger snap cookies in a heat-proof bowl and pour 2 cups of boiling hot water over them.

mock turtle soup recipe adding tomato

Drain the ground beef mix if it is needed. Stir in the ketchup and Worcestershire sauce.

mock turtle soup recipe adding cream

Once dissolved, stir the cookie mixture into the soup pot along with the salt and pepper.

Add 4 cups of water to the pot and stir until everything is well combined.

Bring the soup to boil then reduce to a lower heat to let it simmer.

mock turtle soup recipe adding lemons

Add the lemon slices to the pot, cover, and simmer for 30 minutes, stirring occasionally.

mock turtle soup recipe chopping eggs

Remove the lemon slices and stir in the chopped eggs.

mock turtle soup recipe adding seasoning

Season to taste if needed and then pat yourself on the back as you have made mock turtle soup!

mock turtle soup recipe finished

Serving Suggestions

After you have finished making this culinary delight you can pair Mock Turtle Soup with Sherry, as it had been classically done. Sherry is a fortified wine and is often poured over the soup in small amounts or served in a small glass on the side. Another great side dish serving is a salad. Mediterranean salad works well and adds vegetables to the meal. Caesar and House salads are also good choices. You also can’t go wrong with breadsticks to dip into your soup. Rolls, baguettes cut into smaller slices, or even bruschetta.

See our latest email and just click the blue button on the top to add yourself

How to Store Leftover Mock Turtle Soup

This soup can be stored in the fridge for up to four days. It also can be frozen and enjoyed at a later time. When reheating, whether from the fridge or freezer let it come to a boil before reducing the heat and serving.

Mock Turtle Soup is easy to make and is something that the whole family can enjoy. Mock Turtle soup is good for a nice evening at home with your family when you want a warm comforting meal. With every bite, you can taste the history of the food through the ages. Mock Turtle Soup is timeless, ageless, and full of great flavors.

mock turtle soup recipe ready to eat

Mock Turtle Soup FAQ

  • Why is it called Mock Turtle Soup?

It is called Mock Turtle soup because real turtles are not used in this recipe. It is ‘mocking’ what classic Turtle soup tastes like by replacing turtle with beef. 

  • What is the history of Mock Turtle Soup?

Originally, Mock turtle soup was an English dish created around the 18th century as a nod to imitation green turtle soup. In the United States, Mock Turtle Soup is still popular in Louisiana and other southern areas of the United States.

  • Where can I buy Mock Turtle Soup?

You may be able to buy cans of Mock Turtle Soup in some grocery stores and online from the brand Worthmore. However, this option can be rather expensive as opposed to making it yourself. 

Print off our Mock Turtle Soup Recipe here

Yield: 4

Our Make Mock Turtle Soup Recipe: A Delicious and Easy Treat

mock turtle soup recipe ready to serve

Looking for an easy and delicious recipe? Look no further than our recipe for mock turtle soup! This dish is perfect for a winter meal, and it's sure to please your guests. Plus, it's easy to make - you just
need a few simple ingredients.

Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 45 minutes
Total Time 55 minutes

Ingredients

  • 1 lb ground meat
  • 12 ginger snap cookies
  • ½ yellow onion, chopped
  • 1 cup ketchup
  • ¼ cup Worcestershire sauce
  • 6 lemon slices, thin w/ seeds removed
  • 3 hard boiled eggs, chopped small
  • Salt & pepper, to taste
  • 6 cups water

Instructions

  1. In a large pot cook the ground meat and onions, drain if needed
  2. Stir in the ketchup and Worcestershire sauce
  3. Place the ginger snap cookies in a heat-proof bowl and pour 2 cups of boiling water
    over them
  4. Once dissolved, stir the cookie mixture into the soup pot along with the seasonings
  5. Add 4 cups of water to the pot and stir until everything is well combined
  6. Bring the soup to a boil then reduce the heat to simmer
  7. Add lemon slices to the pot, cover, and simmer for 30 minutes, stirring occasionally
  8. Remove lemon slices and stir in the chopped eggs
  9. Season to taste if needed



Notes

After you have finished making this culinary delight you can pair Mock Turtle Soup with Sherry, as it had been classically done. Sherry is a fortified wine and is often poured over the soup in small amounts or served in a small glass on the side. Another great side dish serving is a salad. Mediterranean salad works well and adds vegetables to the meal. Caesar and House salads are also good choices. You also can’t go wrong with breadsticks to dip into your soup. Rolls, baguettes cut into smaller slices, or even bruschetta.

Recommended Products

As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Nutrition Information:

Yield:

4

Serving Size:

1

Amount Per Serving: Calories: 521Total Fat: 25gSaturated Fat: 9gTrans Fat: 1gUnsaturated Fat: 12gCholesterol: 204mgSodium: 1044mgCarbohydrates: 38gFiber: 1gSugar: 20gProtein: 36g

Other Soup Recipes You May Like

Skip to Recipe